25 Best Personalized Wedding Gifts On Etsy Unique Custom Ideas

Now I’m pretty sure many other brides-to-be out there agree with me on this. The best wedding gifts out there are the ones that are personalized. Etsy is notorious for its custom, handmade gifts, so try changing it up from the typical registry gift and order a special personalized present on Etsy (how’s that for the sweetest wedding wishes?!). All of the wedding gifts on Etsy are super unique so you can bet the future Mrs. doesn’t already have it. Because to be honest, how many ice buckets does a married couple need?! From monogramming to engraving, the customizing possibilities are endless on Etsy. After tons of researching, clicking and scrolling, along with scoping out customer reviews, we’ve made it easy for you by discovering the best 25 personalized wedding gifts on Etsy. Here at Parade.com, we’re all about sharing products we love with our audience. When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.

25 Best Personalized Wedding Gifts on Etsy

1. Personalized Cutting Board - Engraved Cutting Board, $39.00

For the couple that cooks, give the gift of a personalized rectangular wood cutting board.

2. Set of 2, Wedding Champagne Flutes, Mr. and Mrs. Personalized Champagne Glasses, $28.95

This set of engraved champagne flutes comes in 12 different custom templates for you to choose from. Surprise the newlyweds with these swanky glasses. Cheers!

3. Personalized Couple Established Pillow, $23.95

Etsy buyers are raving about this wedding gift idea. This personalized throw pillow matches any couple’s home decor because of its neutral color. You also have the option to pick a different color font for a pop of color!

4. A4 Custom Foil Metallic Song Lyrics Art, Favourite Song Personalized, $27.88

Get the couple’s wedding song lyrics printed on a plaque so they can relive their epic wedding dance. The description says you can even “add a Spotify code which plays your chosen song.”

5. Any Year Wedding Anniversary Date License Plate Sign, $64.95

License to wed! For a wedding gift that’s truly one of a kind, this custom personalized wedding anniversary license plate sign is a showstopper. Each license plate is hand-selected for variety, color, and condition. This is the most unique wedding gift you can get.

6. Personalized Serving Tray, $82.53

Perfect for the newlyweds’ kitchen!

7. Ceramic Custom Bride and Groom Family Platter, $96.00

This gorgeous ceramic custom oval-rimmed platter will be treasured for years to come. Add the bride and groom’s name, along with the year they tied the knot. This plate is also microwave and dishwasher safe so they can use it on holidays or special occasions.

8. Custom Portrait From Photo Watercolor, $30.40

All you need is a photo of the newlyweds and you can have it translated into a watercolor painting on canvas.

9. Custom Doormat, $15.00

Say hello to a fun and functional wedding gift for your friends! This custom doormat features the couple’s last name and the year they got married. The script font gives the mat a fresh and trendy vibe for the modern couple.

10. Personalized Coasters, Set of 4, Wood and Marble Coasters, $31.50

Everyone could use beautiful coasters in their home. Buy Mr. and Mrs. a pack of four marble hexagon coasters personalized with their name and wedding year. They also dual as a perfect housewarming gift.

11. Wedding Package, Custom Cornhole Board, $259.00

If you’re in the bridal party or are close with the newlyweds, you’ll want to spend the $259.00 on this amazing custom cornhole board on Etsy!

12. Custom Wedding Map Gift, $44.60

It’s always a sweet reminder for couples to reminisce on their first date or where they met. You can choose the couple’s city or region for the design of this Etsy custom map. For $44.60, the gift includes an (optional) heart overlay pinpointing the exact lovebirds’ location.

13. Photo Wine Label, $5.00

This custom photo label is only $5 so you can splurge on a nice bottle of wine and make it a high-end wedding gift!

14. Custom Wine Box, $69.00

A rustic-looking wooden wine box with the couple’s name engraved is a wedding gift that will last a lifetime. Add a personal touch with a quote (like the photo above) or keep it simple with their names and wedding date… totally your call!

15. Personalized Metal Sign Custom Last Name Sign, $44.99

A metal frame sign made of 18 gauge steel carved with unique laser technology is a solid wedding gift idea, literally. The couple could showcase their personal emblem in their kitchen or on their outdoor patio.

16. Wedding Gift - Ice Bucket or Wine Bucket - Personalized 3 in 1 Galvanized Set, $109.95

A custom ice bucket that has it all—detailed rope-wrapped metal handles, a dual function ice scoop featuring a bottle opener at the end of the handle. This can be used as an ice bucket or wine bucket so it’s very versatile.

17. Mr. And Mrs. Blanket, Personalized Wedding Blanket, $39.20

This cozy customized blanket is super soft and made of high-quality fabrics so it will not pill, washout, or fade in color. You can choose the type of material and have it monogrammed.

18. Wedding Memory Box, Personalized Wedding Box, $66.00

A thoughtful wedding gift for the married couple in your life is this wedding memory box for $66. They can safely store all their mementos from their wedding in this keepsake chest.

19. Custom Photoscape Standard, $90.00

You’ll really wow the groom and bride with this work of art! The artist blends real-life photos with acrylic impressionism making this a truly one-of-the-kind wedding gift.

20. Personalized Whiskey Decanter Set with Whiskey Glasses, $39.99

This Whiskey Decanter holds 26 oz of the couple’s favorite spirit. There are eight different styling options for you to personalize this new addition to their home bar or bar cart.

21. Personalized Puzzle 210 Pieces, $17.99

Here’s a custom wedding gift that the couple will bond over! A personalized puzzle created from one of their favorite photos is a fun, creative present. Plus, when they’re finished with the puzzle, they can have it framed.

22. Dual Passport Sleeve, Leather Passport Cover, $49.00

This is a functional handmade leather dual passport sleeve that’ll come in handy for the couple’s future travels and honeymoon.

23. Printable Street Signs Digital Photo Art, $21.36

How cool is this black-and-white collaboration of the couples’ names and wedding year?! It looks like an actual street sign.

24. Personalized Wedding Cross, $49.99

For the religious couple, purchase this personalized wedding cross. This is a really special, sacred gift they will cherish in their future and have you to be grateful for.